Did an Armenian Genocide actually happen or not?
DEBATE: Did an “Armenian Genocide” actually happen or not?
CLAIMANT: Armenia
CHALLENGER: Turkey
The stage is set. One of history’s most controversial events is in the spotlight and now, it’s your turn to weigh in.
Was it genocide, or a tragic casualty?
Fact or fiction? Truth or propaganda?
Drop your arguments, bring your sources, and let the facts battle it out.
Only logic survives.
All Replies
Viewing 12 replies - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
Western powers have always wanted to weaken Turkey. The so-called genocide narrative fits neatly into that agenda. Nobody talks about the Turks killed by Armenians. Nobody talks about the imperial forces dividing the empire. This isn’t about truth. It’s about controlling the narrative.
This is nothing but an attempt to smear Turkey. Armenians were not passive victims. they collaborated with invading Russian forces, and yes, many innocent people died on all sides but lets not forget the part where treason against your own nation being involved here. Calling it a genocide is a political tool, not historical truth. Turkey has opened its archives. Why won’t Armenia do the same?
If 1.5 million people died under any other empire, we’d call it what it is. But because it’s Turkey, and Turkey is NATO, suddenly it’s ‘complex’? No. The archives are there. The witness reports are there. The maps, the numbers, the orders, they’re all there. This isn’t denial. It’s complicity.
It was genocide. Full stop. The Turks didn’t ‘relocate’ Armenians, they marched them into deserts with no food or water. They raped, mutilated, and butchered civilians. Babies were thrown into rivers. Pregnant women were cut open. This isn’t fog of war. This was intent. And the fact that it’s still denied, still debated, just shows how spineless the global community is when ‘strategic alliances’ get in the way of moral clarity.
This isn’t just about Armenians. It’s about what the world allowed. Hitler studied it. ‘Who remembers the Armenians?’ he asked — and then planned the Holocaust. Genocide denial isn’t passive. It’s a signal to future killers that the world will look away. If we let this lie stand, we make room for the next atrocity.
Every time someone says ‘it’s complicated,’ another victim gets buried twice. First by bullets, now by bullshit. This is what historical gaslighting looks like.
This wasn’t collateral damage. It was logistics. Trains. Camps. Mass graves. Bureaucracy. You don’t get to say ‘war is messy’ when the goal was ethnic erasure. Own it, or shut up.
The Ottoman archives are full of it. German officers witnessed it. American diplomats reported it in real-time. The only people denying it are the ones who benefit from the lie. Turkey doesn’t want accountability it wants silence.
Imagine watching your grandparents disappear, your churches burned, your history erased and then being told it didn’t happen. That’s what denial looks like. And it’s not ignorance. It’s strategy.
Why is this still a debate in 2025? Over a million Armenians were marched into deserts, shot, burned, starved and we’re still tiptoeing around the word ‘genocide’? Call it what it was. Pretending it’s controversial is just cowardice.
Viewing 12 replies - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.
While this is a great tragedy and its a very saddening moment in human history for everyone, the extra zero added to the death toll is easily proven through even by their own church’s clearly unrealistic changes in total population throughout a few years and the fact that they sided with their own country’s #1 enemy and plotted against their own country kind of disqualifies this tragedy to be labeled a genocide. No one is proud of this history and it was also labeled by Ataturk as the darkest moment in ottoman history. A time when ottoman empire was pretty much already defeat, with no control of the empire by a very unified Europe focused against the ottoman empire which was an Islamic caliphate at the time and not to mention Russia on the other side, a whole other animal whom was planning to attack the ottoman empire right where the Armenians were, ironically, the story is long and interesting. We should all get together to talk about it instead of avoiding proper debates.
My personal opinion on this is that the Armenians have been used by the west and Russia for too long. If you do some research on all theyve gone through, even recent history, you can always somehow point the finger at their “best friend country” as they always refer to them for whatever reason. Just something to think about for Armenians.